Tag Archives: callbacks

Template Method Pattern using JavaScript callbacks

JavaScript callbacks are usually discussed in terms of asynchronous behavior. Primary examples given of this are event handlers in the browser or XHR. Callbacks are used so much in JavaScript that there is even a new evil in the world, Callback Hell.

Callbacks are very useful for more familiar coding tasks and it doesn’t have to be about asynchronous services, or journeys into the compsci land of Functional Programming, or Monad this or that.

Template Method Pattern
The term ‘template’ is not related to templates as used in text substitution libraries. This pattern is used when an algorithm or operation has common behavior and the uncommon behavior can be ‘substituted” or deferred by various means.

Though this pattern is usually presented in terms of Inheritance in Class-based Object Oriented Programming, that is just an implementation example. JavaScript can and does implement this pattern; it is just not called by that name.

Simple example
Lets give a very very simple example of what this means. Lets say you have some widget on a web page that presents to the user some recipe based on some input conditions or properties. For simplicity, lets assume that this can be done in one function that consists of a series of statements that are the same except for a few steps.

The usual way to do this is to create multiple functions that change the widget in the required manner, or create one function that uses conditional statements to invoke the correct steps that vary for each type of recipe.

Below in listing 1, we have the behavior for the widget. Some statements come before and after the call of the doSomething() function. The problem with this code is that if we have to do different things, we must complicate the conditional or create other widgetRecipe type of functions that perform the recipe differently.

Listing 1, psuedo code of conditional use
functions widgetRecipe(){
statements before
statements after

Example with callbacks
Since we have a process that differs in only one or more “steps”, the Template Method Pattern is applicable.

The recipe function in listing 1, can be simplified by replacing the conditional statement with the actual function to invoke. Functions in JavaScript are objects, so can be assigned to a variable.

In listing 2, we use the argument name secretSauce for that function that will be passed in. Some tutorials out on the web use the name ‘callBack’ to make it obvious that this is a callback function. Note how the passed in function is invoked, using “()”.

Listing 2, psuedo code using callback
functions widgetRecipe(secretSauce){
statements before
statements after

We can define that function as: var bitterSauce = function(){ alert(“Add a dash of pepper”);}
Then invoke widgetRecipe like: widgetRecipe(bitterSauce);

One famous programmer, Chuck Moore, inventor of the FORTH language, said: don’t decide, compute. Here the function is computed elsewhere, perhaps a table of some kind.

Of course, you can have multiple callback arguments to a function, even an array of callback functions. You can even inline callback functions or make them anonymous. And, a callback function could have arguments too.

Used in certain ways, a Callback function is a Closure. This can have, if not used correctly, very subtle issues. In addition, if the callback function uses this internally, you have to invoke it a certain way.

Some of the links below give more information on how to use callbacks and things to watch for.

Real world use?
I am almost done solving a programming problem where I have a ‘Callback Hell’ situation, and to make matters worse, the various slices of this hell needed to be reused. I think I solved it by abstracting out the variable behavior into a callback. Lets see if it survives code review.

Since JavaScript is Object Oriented, but not via Classes as in Java, it can do inheritance, via prototypes. Thus, the Template Method Pattern can be implemented using prototypical inheritance. This approach is present here, JavaScript Template Method.


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.